Idlewild – Mark Burns
Idlewild has problems, yet despite intense ADHD jitters it stays a fun, slick and novel ride. It’s a musical made for MTV.
OutKast duo André 3000 and Big Boi put scratches and beats on the speakeasy scene in this frenetic musical.
Idlewild, Georgia, is a podunk peachville of the early 1930s. Best friends Rooster (Antwan A. Patton aka Big Boi, ATL) and Percival (André Benjamin aka André 3000, Four Brothers) help light up the night scene’s only bright spot, Sunshine Ace’s swinging juke joint Church. Honorific bootlegger Spats keeps Church wet, but as he tries to retire from the game, flunky Trumpy makes a power grab by offing his boss and Ace. Now Rooster is in charge of the place, and he must figure out how to avoid being squeezed to death by the new crime boss. Meanwhile, introvert Percival meets his muse in Angel, pushing him into love and toward his musical dream.
There’s promise here. Imagine: OutKast hip-hop artists known for their transformative melding of musical influences, molding their talents to embody a speakeasy musical. Sweet. Hip-hop tinted tunes on a ’30s-era stage may seem odd, but the mish-mashing of eras has worked before. A Knight’s Tale successfully combined rock and Chaucer for a fun flick. Moulin Rouge was pop brilliance on top of 1920s Paris. More obscurely, the anime Samurai Champloo blended Edo-period samurai with hip-hop aesthetic to great effect. So there’s reason to believe this film could be a gem.
At its best, it is. Brilliant, even. The opening sequence of the friends’ childhoods is particularly strong, as creative editing of shots and stills makes for a creative pop-and-lock visual effect. Here, the story gets a good start as the friends’ personalities are established and the film finds its vibe with a snappy overlay of hip-hop on period scenes. Song-and-dance numbers are also strong, especially in Big Boi’s turns as Rooster. Director and writer Bryan Barber, a prominent hip-hop video director, shines brightest in this material. There are even bright flashes of inspiration throughout the dramatic bridges, as Barber entertains with creative visual experimentation so emblematic of the music video genre.
Ultimately, though, you can tell Barber is a feature-film rookie. For starters, his first script is choppy and incomplete. While the tale and ensuing action are fun and interesting, he can’t quite make the cool cohere. Percival and Rooster are on two separate story paths that rarely intersect or directly relate. Instead their arcs are intermingled in an often-confusing mélange of cut scenes. Rooster’s tale tends to dominate, as it’s the most complete blend of humor, drama, music and action. Percival, in contrast, explores a neglected emotional storyline undercut by short development of the story of budding love, inner conflict and paternal issues.
Slapdash video aesthetic, plus preoccupation with nifty visuals, reduce the dramatic portion to rat-a-tat Cliffs Notes summation rather than a whole tale. Once beyond childhood, the story increasingly jumps around without transition or explanation, leaving holes for assumption to fill. As the film rolls along, the director seems to grow more impatient with storytelling, pinballing off major plot points to the finish. It becomes a string of music videos connected by thinning strands of plot.
The tunage is a blast, jiving from jazz age to hip-hop with a little slow guitar tossed in and every mix of genres in between. The variety can be hectic; there is little to soften transitions between the omnipresent record-scratch tracks and other styles. Transitions from drama to dance are often weak, as well. But the music shines through, injecting the film with infectious energy.
Acting, when given the time, is also done well. Journeyman actors Benjamin and Patton fill out their characters nicely, and Terrence Howard makes a good villain as Trumpy. Ben Vereen is seen too little as Percy Sr., while supporting actors Ving Rhames and Macy Gray plus a smart cameo by Patti LaBelle enrich the film.
Idlewild has problems, yet despite intense ADHD jitters it stays a fun, slick and novel ride. It’s a musical made for MTV.
Fair musical drama • R • 90 min.